Immigration judge · Buffalo Immigration Court (BUF)

Judge Mary C. Baumgarten

Last 12 months: Oct 2025 – Sep 2026 EOIR data as of Sep 30, 2026 Last decision: Sep 2026 With decisions since 1999 in the public data
Less relief than the other judges in this court
How is this compared?

This judge: 10 of 2,128 (0.5 %) got relief (includes their cases in other courts). The other judges in the court: 95 of 3,345 (2.8 %). We say "more" or "less" only when the difference is statistically clear (two-proportion test, 95%); otherwise "similar".

Decisions over 12 months

Decisions 2,128 Oct 2025 – Sep 2026
Grants relief 0.5 % Court 1.9 % · Nation 2.3 %
Removal order 88.6 % Court 73.6 % · Nation 76.9 %
Decided in absentia 31.3 % Court 24.5 % · Nation 46.4 %
Had an attorney 47.9 % Court 51.1 % · Nation 37.7 %
How long cases take 27 months 821 days (median) · Court 764 days · Nation 827 days

In plain words

Fewer than 1 in 100 cases this judge decided got relief (10 of 2,128).

3 of every 10 cases were decided in absentia, without the person at the hearing. Going to your hearing is the most important thing you can do.

With and without an attorney, the share with relief was similar (0.7 % and 0.3 %).

Of their 2,128 decisions, 10 ended with relief, 123 with the case closed, 110 with voluntary departure and 1,885 with a removal order.

How the decisions ended
OutcomeDecisions%
Relief100.5 %
Case closed1235.8 %
Voluntary departure1105.2 %
Removal order1,88588.6 %
Decided in absentia66631.3 %

This judge, the court and the nation

Grants relief
Removal order
Decided in absentia

With Mary C. Baumgarten, the share of cases with relief is 0.5 %: lower than at the Buffalo court (1.9 %) and lower than nationwide (2.3 %).

With Mary C. Baumgarten, the share of removal orders is 88.6 %: higher than at the Buffalo court (73.6 %) and higher than nationwide (76.9 %).

With Mary C. Baumgarten, the share of cases decided in absentia is 31.3 %: higher than at the Buffalo court (24.5 %) and lower than nationwide (46.4 %).

With Mary C. Baumgarten, the share of people with an attorney is 47.9 %: lower than at the Buffalo court (51.1 %) and higher than nationwide (37.7 %).

Cases with Mary C. Baumgarten take longer than at the Buffalo court: a median of 821 days versus 764.

Compared with other judges

  • Ranked 6 of 7 for relief among the judges of their court (1 = most relief).
  • Ranked 3 of 7 for cases decided in absentia (1 = most in absentia).
  • Ranked 4 of 7 for speed (1 = fastest).
  • Grants relief more often than 19 of every 100 judges nationwide (among 872 judges with 50 or more decisions).

Decisions per month (Oct 2025 – Sep 2026)

The busiest month was Jun 2026 (357 decisions) and the quietest Nov 2025 (92).

Decisions per month (Oct 2025 – Sep 2026)
MonthDecisionsReliefIn absentiaVs. prior month
Oct 202598028—
Nov 202592035down
Dec 2025127142up
Jan 2026174135up
Feb 2026129128down
Mar 2026205044up
Apr 2026143129down
May 2026160046up
Jun 20263571207up
Jul 2026192164down
Aug 2026221452up
Sep 2026230056up

Months with fewer than 5 decisions are dotted: with so few cases, that month's percentage says little.

By nationality

The nationality with the most decisions before Mary C. Baumgarten is Ecuador (418), followed by Venezuela, Colombia, Cuba and Mexico. The highest share with relief was for people from Mexico (0.9 %).

Country of originDecisionsReliefIn absentia
Ecuador4180.0 %39.2 %
Venezuela4030.0 %36.0 %
Colombia1750.0 %31.4 %
Cuba1210.0 %3.3 %
Mexico1180.9 %30.5 %

Only countries with 25 or more decisions with this judge; cases without a recorded nationality are not included.

With and without an attorney

DecisionsRelief
With an attorney1,0190.7 %
Without an attorney1,1090.3 %

Where this judge decides

Get alerts for your court case and your monthly judge report Change of date, room or judge: we alert you instantly. Free.
Subscribe free
Alerts for your court case + your monthly judge report. Free.
Download and subscribe free
Free Immigration court · EOIR

Want to know the instant your court case changes?

We alert you to any change of date, room or judge, and each month we email you your judge’s report.

31.3 % of Judge Mary’s cases were decided in absentia. Don’t miss a date.

Free
Inmigreat

Want to know the instant your court case changes?

Alerts for any change of date, room or judge + your monthly judge report.

3 of 10 cases with Judge Mary were decided in absentia. Don’t miss a date.

Download and subscribe free

iOS and Android · official EOIR data

Verified lawyers

Do you need a lawyer for your case?

At Inmigreat we connect you with verified immigration lawyers.

With Judge Mary received relief:
EOIR data Sep 2025 – Aug 2026 · does not predict your case
0.7 % with a lawyer
0.3 % without a lawyer
Get Inmigreat iOS and Android
Verified lawyers
Inmigreat

Do you need a lawyer for your case?

At Inmigreat we connect you with verified immigration lawyers.

With Judge Mary, 0.7 % of those with a lawyer received relief. Without a lawyer: 0.3 %.

Get Inmigreat

EOIR data Sep 2025 – Aug 2026 · does not predict your case

Is this your judge? See your case.

With your A-number, the Inmigreat app shows what matters for your case, not the average.

People from your country with this judge Personal data, available in the app. vs. all of their cases
Unlock for free

See it in the Inmigreat app with your A-number. It's free.

App Store Google Play
Your type of relief Personal data, available in the app. asylum, cancellation, adjustment…
Unlock for free

See it in the Inmigreat app with your A-number. It's free.

App Store Google Play
Cases like yours Personal data, available in the app. country + relief + attorney
Unlock for free

See it in the Inmigreat app with your A-number. It's free.

App Store Google Play
Your next hearing Personal data, available in the app. date, time and type
Unlock for free

See it in the Inmigreat app with your A-number. It's free.

App Store Google Play

Other judges at Buffalo Immigration Court

See the Buffalo court →

Frequently asked questions

How many cases did Mary C. Baumgarten decide in the last 12 months?

2,128 decisions between Oct 2025 and Sep 2026, per EOIR data as of Sep 30, 2026.

How often does Mary C. Baumgarten grant relief?

In 10 of 2,128 decisions (0.5 %). In the court the share was 1.9 % and nationwide 2.3 %.

What does "in absentia" mean?

That the case was decided without the person at the hearing. With Mary C. Baumgarten it happened in 31.3 % of decisions. Going to your hearing is the most important thing you can do.

Where does this data come from?

From official EOIR case data, published in its FOIA Library. We count the immigration judge's decisions over the last 12 full months.

Sources

Not legal advice. These figures describe past decisions and do not predict your case. Talk to an immigration attorney.

Inmigreat is not part of the government and is not endorsed by USCIS or EOIR.